One impetus for President Trump’s controversial ban on citizens from
specific Middle Eastern countries is to reduce the number of Muslims entering
the USA, as if Muslims in general were dangerous, rather than simply using the
nation’s intelligence agencies to identify risky people and denying them entry.
That impetus went unstated in the ban’s legal language but was widely bruited
about last fall on the campaign trail.
is rather too little, too late. The USA already counts many Muslims among its
citizens, with Islam coming up on Judaism for the honor of being the nation’s
second largest religion. While this sounds sizeable, in percentage terms it is
not. Judaism stands at roughly 4 percent of Americans, while Islam is about 3
percent. Compared to the percentage of self-professed Christians, which a 2014
Pew survey puts at over 70 percent, this is rather small. But, like Judaism,
Islam is here to stay.
have been in America since Muslim slaves came with the Spanish in the 16th
century. During America’s Civil War in the mid-19th century, Muslims served in
the North’s army; one became a captain in the Illinois Infantry while another,
Hajji Ali, was in charge of its Camel Military Corps in what is now Arizona.
And, their numbers have increased gradually over the decades, with the biggest
increase since World War II.
last observation is significant, for it means that Muslims did not enter during
the largest period of immigration in USA history, from the 1880s to the late
1920s. Millions of immigrants entered America during this time, most from
Europe. Until that time, America had been largely Protestant, but now large
numbers of Catholics and Jews came to the country. Indeed, this is when Judaism
become the nation’s second largest religion.
adjustment to American society can be instructive for understanding the changes
American Islam is presently undergoing. In the early 20th century, newly
arrived Jews found the USA quite different from Europe. And, this required
changes to the practices they had followed.
give (at least) two kinds of instructions to their adherents: how to worship
and relate to the divine, and how to relate to the people and society in which
their adherents live.
worship rules are internal to the religion and tend to remain fairly stable,
rules about relating to society change as that society changes. If a religion
moves from a totalitarian society to a democratic society, for example, or from
a tolerant to an intolerant one, it will, by necessity, change the way it
relates to the new society.
how does a religion know when the changes are OK? Do they fit with the
centuries and/or millennia of religious tradition? Those decisions are made by
trained religious leaders.
Judaism, rabbis are the leaders authorized to make such decisions. At first,
rabbis came from Europe along with their congregants. They were used to
European ways of doing things rather than American ways. Change, therefore, was
the pace of adjustment picked up when Judaism created seminaries --
graduate-level educational schools to transform young Americans into American
rabbis to lead the American Jewish community. Within a generation, American
Judaism was led by rabbis who understood America because they were American,
not transplanted Europeans. These rabbis reshaped the character of Judaism’s social
relations to help the religion and its members fit into American society.
in America is at a similar stage right now. Immigration has increased the
American Muslim population and the number of mosques. And, some trained Islamic
leaders, “imams,” have arrived. Many mosques are led by devoted and dedicated
the past few years, the Islamic community has begun to organize seminaries for
training young American Muslims as religious leaders. But, it is a slow
process. Nationally, about half a dozen seminaries have programs, but none are
yet fully accredited by the USA’s higher education accrediting bodies. Hartford
Seminary -- a multifaith institution -- has an accredited Muslim chaplaincy
degree, but even that falls short of a complete training for Muslim religious
the end, while American Muslims have lived here for generations, Islam, as a
religious organization, is still in its early stages. The foundation of
seminaries is a solid start and, within a few years, they will begin graduating
American native imams. That will be a milestone in the advancement of our
country’s religious liberty.
Labels: America, ban, education, imam, Islam, Judaism, Muslims, rabbi, seminary, Trump